| Matt DeWitt 1996 Johnson City Cardinals Card # NNO (9) | Matt DeWitt 1997 Best Peoria Chiefs Card # 8 | Matt DeWitt 1998 Blueline Q-Cards Carolina League Top Prospects Card # 3 | Matt DeWitt 1998 Blueline Q-Cards Prince William Cannons Card # 6 |
| Matt DeWitt 1998 Team Best - Autographs Signature Series Card # NNO (18) | Matt DeWitt 1999 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects Card # 40 | Matt DeWitt 1999 Upper Deck SP Top Prospects President's Edition Card # 40 |