| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 1 | Chris Maloney | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 2 | Rich Folkers | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 3 | Matt Morris | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 4 | Alan Benes | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 5 | Steve Biermann | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 6 | Efrain Contreras | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 7 | Keith Conway | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 8 | Frank J. Garcia | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 9 | Matt Golden | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 10 | Scarborough Green | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 11 | Ryan Hall | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 12 | Yates Hall | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 13 | Rick Heiserman | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 14 | Joe Jumonville | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 15 | Marcus Logan | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 16 | Jesus Lugo | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 17 | Mike Matvey | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 18 | Keith McDonald | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 19 | Kevin McNeill | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 20 | John Mendez | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 21 | Francisco Morales | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 22 | Luis Ordaz | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 23 | Yudith Ozorio | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 24 | Placido Polanco | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 25 | Dan Pontes | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 26 | Brian Reed | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 27 | Chris Richard | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 28 | Steve Santucci | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 29 | Blake Stein | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 30 | Mike Windham | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 1 | Roy Silver | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 2 | Ray Searage | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 3 | Bert Boyd | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 4 | Armando Almanza | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 5 | Greg Almond | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 6 | Corey Avrard | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 7 | Adam Benes | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 8 | Nate Dishington | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 9 | Robert Donnelly | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 10 | Kevin Foderaro | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 11 | Ossie Garcia | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 12 | Keith Glauber | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 13 | Chris Haas | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 14 | Andy J. Hall | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 15 | Miguel Inzunza | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 16 | Jose Jimenez | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 17 | Nick Kast | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 18 | Jason Lariviere | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 19 | Travis McClendon | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 20 | Shawn McNally | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 21 | Bret Mueller | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 22 | Juan Munoz | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 23 | Isaias Nunez | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 24 | Cliff Politte | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 25 | Britt Reames | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 26 | Miguel Rivera | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 27 | Kerry Robinson | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 28 | Mark Roettgen | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 29 | Travis Welch | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 30 | Jason Woolf | 1996 | Best Peoria Chiefs | |
| 1 | Scott Melvin | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 2 | Darrell Betts | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 3 | Bryan Britt | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 4 | Ken Cameron | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 5 | Bryan Clark | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 6 | Kevin Crafton | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 7 | Lou Deman | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 8 | Tony Falciglia | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 9 | Keith Finnerty | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 10 | Joe Freitas | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 11 | Keith Gallagher | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 12 | Andrew Gordon | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 13 | Greg Heffernan | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 14 | Ruben Jimenez | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 15 | Brad Kennedy | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 16 | Stacy Kleiner | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 17 | Jeff Love | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 18 | Brian Mazurek | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 19 | Mike McDougal | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 20 | Mark Nussbeck | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 21 | Jason Pollock | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 22 | Jay Reames | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 23 | Jorge Roque | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 24 | Dave Schmidt | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 25 | Andy Schofield | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 26 | Gene Stechschulte | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 27 | Hector Ugueto | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 28 | Jon Ward | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 29 | Adam West | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 30 | Paul Wilders | 1996 | Best New Jersey Cardinals | |
| 56 | Brady Raggio | 1996 | Best AA All-Stars | |
| 2 | Jeff Berblinger | 1996 | Best Texas League All-Stars | |
| 12 | Eli Marrero | 1996 | Best Texas League All-Stars | |
| 14 | Brady Raggio | 1996 | Best Texas League All-Stars | |
| 19 | Andy J. Hall | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 20 | Juan Munoz | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 21 | Cliff Politte | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 22 | Britt Reames | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 23 | Kerry Robinson | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 24 | Travis Welch | 1996 | Best Midwest League All-Stars | |
| 19 | Brent Butler | 1996 | Best Appalachian League All-Stars | |
| 20 | Billy Deck | 1996 | Best Appalachian League All-Stars | |
| 21 | Luis Saturria | 1996 | Best Appalachian League All-Stars | |
| 226 | Mike Busby | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 227 | Mike Gulan | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 228 | Chris Haas | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 229 | Jeff Matulevich | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 230 | Steve Montgomery | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 231 | Matt Morris | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 232 | Bret Wagner | 1996 | Fleer Excel Minors | Scan |
| 10 | Matt Morris | 1996 | Fleer Excel First Year Phenoms | Scan |
| 10 | John Frascatore | Signature Rookies Old Judge | ||
| 18 | T.J. Mathews | Signature Rookies Old Judge | ||
| 20 | Jeff McNeely | Signature Rookies Old Judge | ||
| 26 | Mark Petkovsek | Signature Rookies Old Judge | ||
| 31 | Willie Smith | Signature Rookies Old Judge | ||
| P5 | Matt Morris | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Peak Picks | |
| P5 | Matt Morris | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Peak Picks Signatures | |
| R5 | Alan Benes | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Rising Stars | |
| 5 | Alan Benes | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Rising Stars Signatures | |
| 10 | John Frascatore | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Signatures | |
| 18 | T.J. Mathews | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Signatures | |
| 20 | Jeff McNeely | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Signatures | |
| 26 | Mark Petkovsek | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Signatures | |
| 31 | Willie Smith | 1996 | Signature Rookies Old Judge Signatures | |
| NNO (1) | Antonio Abell | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (2) | Brian Barfield | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (3) | Aaron Bruns | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (4) | Brent Butler | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (5) | Isaac Byrd | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (6) | Stubby Clapp | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (7) | Billy Deck | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (8) | Jose M. DeLeon | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (9) | Matt DeWitt | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (10) | Chris Dooley | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (11) | Brad Evans | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (12) | Cordell Farley | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (13) | Jimmy Gargiulo | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (14) | Toribio Guzman | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (15) | Rodger Harris | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (16) | Todd Hogan | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (17) | Shawn Hogge | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (18) | Ryan Kritscher | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (19) | Jason Lee | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (20) | Jose Leon | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (21) | Jesus Lugo | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (22) | Pepe McNeal | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (23) | Richard Mear | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (24) | Steve Norris | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (25) | Tim Onofrei | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (26) | Steve Reed | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (27) | Tim Riegert | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (28) | Ruben Rosario | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (29) | Luis Saturria | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (30) | Paul Tanner | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (31) | Steve Turco | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (32) | John Tuttle | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (33) | Clint Weibl | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (34) | Logo Card | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals | |
| NNO (35) | Team Checklist | 1996 | Johnson City Cardinals |
