| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 17 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 26 | Fernando Tatis | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 58 | J.D. Drew | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 102 | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 107 | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 115 | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 166 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 172 | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 177 | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 189 | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars | |
| 17 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 26 | Fernando Tatis | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 58 | J.D. Drew | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 102 | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 107 | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 115 | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 166 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 172 | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 177 | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 189 | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars Metallic Blue | |
| 1 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars All-Star Authority | |
| BG | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars Autographs | |
| OS | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars Autographs | |
| RA | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars Autographs | |
| 3 | J.D. Drew | 2000 | Topps Stars Game Gear Jerseys | |
| 1 | Bob Gibson | 2000 | Topps Stars Progression | |
| 1 | Rick Ankiel | 2000 | Topps Stars Progression | |
| 3 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars Progression | |
| 6 | Ozzie Smith | 2000 | Topps Stars Progression | |
| 3 | Mark McGwire | 2000 | Topps Stars Walk of Fame |