| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 1 | Albert Pujols | 2004 | Upper Deck Vintage Old Judge Color Parallel | |
| 112 | Bo Hart | 2004 | Upper Deck Vintage Old Judge Color Parallel | |
| 133 | Scott Rolen | 2004 | Upper Deck Vintage Old Judge Color Parallel | |
| 170 | Matt Morris | 2004 | Upper Deck Vintage Old Judge Color Parallel | |
| 236 | J.D. Drew | 2004 | Upper Deck Vintage Old Judge Color Parallel |