Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Art Mahaffey	Phi-N
2	Mickey Mantle	NY-A
3	Ron Santo	Chi-N
4	Bud Daley	KC-A
5	Roger Maris	NY-A
6	Eddie Yost	LA-A
7	Minnie Minoso	Chi-A
8	Dick Groat	Pit-N
9	Frank Malzone	Bos-A
10	Dick Donovan	Was-A
11	Eddie Mathews	Mil-N
12	Jim Lemon	Min-A
13	Chuck Estrada	Bal-A
14	Ken Boyer	StL-N
15	Harvey Kuenn	SF-N
16	Ernie Broglio	StL-N
17	Rocky Colavito	Det-A
18	Ted Kluszewski	LA-A
19	Ernie Banks	Chi-N
20	Al Kaline	Det-A
21	Ed Bailey	Cin-N
22	Jim Perry	Cle-A
23	Willie Mays	SF-N
24	Bill Mazeroski	Pit-N
25	Gus Triandos	Bal-A
26	Don Drysdale	LA-N
27	Frank Herrera	Phi-N
28	Earl Battey	Min-A
29	Warren Spahn	Mil-N
30	Gene Woodling	Was-A
31	Frank Robinson	Cin-N
32	Pete Runnels	Bos-A
33	Woodie Held	Cle-A
34	Norm Larker	LA-N
35	Luis Aparicio	Chi-A
36	Bill Tuttle	KC-A