| Card # | Player name | Team | Comment |
| A | Wade Boggs | ||
| B | George Brett | ||
| C | Andre Dawson | ||
| D | Darrell Evans | ||
| E | Dwight Gooden | ||
| F | Rickey Henderson | ||
| G | Tom Lasorda | ||
| H | Fred Lynn | ||
| I | Mark McGwire | ||
| J | Dave Parker | ||
| K | Jeff Reardon | ||
| L | Rick Reuschel | ||
| M | Jim Rice | ||
| N | Cal Ripken Jr. | ||
| O | Nolan Ryan | ||
| P | Ryne Sandberg |