April 2, 1877 at Indianapolis
Indianapolis 5, St. Louis 3
GameID g04021877-01

| Indianapolis
| Joe Quest | 2b | | Trick McSorley | 3b | | Denny Mack | ss | | Charles Houtz | 1b | | Mike Golden | lf | | Silver Flint | c | | Fred Warner | cf | | Adam Rocap | rf | | Ed Nolan | p | | | St. Louis
| John Clapp | c | | Mike McGeary | 2b | | Joe Battin | 3b | | Davy Force | ss | | Jack Remsen | cf | | Mike Dorgan | lf | | Art Croft | 1b | | Joe Blong | rf | | Tricky Nichols | p | |