April 23, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 6, Indianapolis 4GameID g04231877-06
| Bob Addy | rf |
| Lip Pike | cf |
| Charley Jones | 1b |
| Jimmy Hallinan | 2b |
| Ned Cuthbert | lf |
| Will Foley | 3b |
| Nat Hicks | c |
| Amos Booth | ss |
| Bobby Mitchell | p |
| Joe Quest | 2b |
| Trick McSorley | cf |
| Denny Mack | ss |
| Charles Houtz | 1b |
| Mike Golden | lf |
| Silver Flint | c |
| Fred Warner | 3b |
| Adam Rocap | rf |
| Ed Nolan | p |
