May 12, 1877 at Rochester
Rochester 2, Allegheny 0GameID g05121877-04
| Steve Brady | 2b |
| Joe Simmons | cf |
| Harry Luff | ss |
| Ed Shattuck | rf |
| Jim Tipper | lf |
| Jack Madden | 3b |
| Ed Caskin | c |
| Charles Purroy | p |
| Ed Pond | 1b |
| Candy Nelson | ss |
| Ed Williamson | 2b |
| Tom Dolan | c |
| Jake Goodman | 1b |
| Al Nichols | 3b |
| Bill Holbert | rf |
| George Creamer | lf |
| Russ McKelvy | cf |
| Pud Galvin | p |
