May 12, 1877 at Wheeling
Wheeling Standard 4, Buckeyes 5GameID g05121877-05
| Chappy Lane | c |
| Sam Moffat | 1b |
| Charles Junkins | ss |
| Jack Glasscock | 3b |
| Deacon Hagan | p |
| Sam Barkley | 2b |
| Robinson | cf |
| John Gallagher | lf |
| Thomas Wilson | rf |
| Frank Fleet | 2b |
| Mike Burke | ss |
| Eddie Booth | rf |
| John Magner | cf |
| Edward Callahan | p |
| Harry Spence | 3b |
| Chub Sullivan | 1b |
| Billy Barnie | c |
| George Strief | lf |
