May 18, 1877 at Columbus
Buckeyes 6, Champion City 2
GameID g05181877-01

| Buckeyes
| Frank Fleet | c | | Mike Burke | ss | | Eddie Booth | rf | | Edward Callahan | lf | | Harry Spence | 3b | | Chub Sullivan | 1b | | Billy Barnie | cf | | George Strief | 2b | | Jim McCormick | p | | | Champion City
| Andy Cummins | ss | | Emanuel Snyder | 2b | | Guy Hecker | 1b | | George Miller | c | | Williams | cf | | T Welch | lf | | Wright | cf | | Bobby Mitchell | p | | Mike Brannock | 3b | |