May 28, 1877 at Erie
Erie 2, Buckeyes 4GameID g05281877-02
| Bill Smiley | ss |
| Lewis Talley | rf |
| Jack Leary | p |
| Frank Heifer | 1b |
| James Curry | 2b |
| Mike Dillon | cf |
| Marr Phillips | lf |
| Michael Quinn | 3b |
| Frank Thompson | c |
| Frank Fleet | cf |
| Mike Burke | ss |
| Eddie Booth | rf |
| Edward Callahan | lf |
| Harry Spence | 3b |
| Chub Sullivan | 1b |
| Billy Barnie | c |
| George Strief | 2b |
| Jim McCormick | p |
