July 19, 1877 at Chicago
Chicago 3, Syracuse Stars 2
GameID g07191877-05

| Chicago
| Jimmy Hallinan | rf | | Cal McVey | c | | Cap Anson | 3b | | John Peters | ss | | Dave Eggler | cf | | Al Spalding | 1b | | Paul Hines | 2b | | George Bradley | p | | John Glenn | lf | | | Syracuse Stars
| Pete Hotaling | c | | Billy Geer | ss | | Dick Higham | rf | | Alex McKinnon | 1b | | Jack Farrell | 2b | | Harry McCormick | p | | Mike Mansell | lf | | Hick Carpenter | 3b | | Jim Clinton | cf | |