August 7, 1877 at Wheeling
Wheeling Standard 4, Buckeyes 5GameID g08071877-04
| Chappy Lane | |
| Sam Moffat | |
| George Vennum | |
| Jack Glasscock | |
| Deacon Hagan | |
| Sam Barkley | |
| Robinson | |
| Harry Lukens | |
| Samuel Wilkinson |
| Mike Burke | |
| Charlie Pabor | |
| Edward Callahan | |
| Chub Sullivan | |
| King Kelly | |
| George Strief | |
| Harry Spence | |
| Jim McCormick | |
| T Welch |
