September 28, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 5, Chicago 5
GameID g09281877-05

| Cincinnati
| Lip Pike | 2b | | Jack Manning | cf | | Charley Jones | lf | | Bob Addy | rf | | Levi Meyerle | ss | | Chub Sullivan | 1b | | Will Foley | 3b | | George Miller | c | | Bobby Mitchell | p | | | Chicago
| Ross Barnes | 2b | | Cal McVey | p & c | | Cap Anson | 3b & c | | John Peters | ss | | Paul Hines | rf | | Al Spalding | 1b | | Dave Eggler | cf | | George Bradley | 3b & p | | John Glenn | lf | |