October 5, 1877 at Rochester
Rochester 4, Crickets 5
GameID g10051877-03 Afternoon

| Rochester
| Steve Brady | 2b | | Ed Caskin | 3b | | Charles Junkins | 1b | | Jim Tipper | lf | | Doc Kennedy | c | | Harry Luff | cf | | Ed Shattuck | rf | | Ike Van Burkalow | p | | Richard Dixon | ss | | | Crickets
| Blondie Purcell | rf | | John McGuinness | 1b | | Hardy Richardson | cf | | John Richmond | ss | | Pop Smith | 3b | | Ed Kennedy | lf | | Buttercup Dickerson | 2b | | Joseph Roche | c | | Nicholas Alcott | p | |