May 5, 1877 at Wheeling WV
Wheeling Standard 21, Bethany 3Game 143 (GameID g05051877-09)
| Chappy Lane | c |
| Sam Moffat | |
| Charles Junkins | ss |
| Jack Glasscock | |
| Deacon Hagan | p |
| Sam Barkley | |
| Rick Robinson | |
| John Gallagher | |
| Carney |
| Winbigler | |
| Mercer | |
| Lamar | |
| Colbert | |
| Meyers | |
| Hull | |
| Hayden | |
| Garvey | |
| Kemper |
