May 21, 1877 at Guelph ON
Maple Leaf 5, Philadelphia Athletic 4Game 257 (GameID g05211877-02)
| Tommy Smith | lf |
| William Smith | cf |
| Richard Dixon | ss |
| James Sullivan | p |
| Scott Hastings | rf |
| William Lapham | 1b |
| Marshall Quinton | 3b & c |
| Henry Gillespie | 2b & 3b |
| Walsh | c |
| James Hewer | 2b |
| Dave Eggler | cf |
| John Shetzline | 2b |
| Al Reach | rf |
| William Coon | 3b |
| Wes Fisler | 1b |
| Charles Fulmer | ss |
| Johnny Ryan | lf |
| Sam Weaver | p |
| Edward McGlynn | c |
