September 14, 1877 at Janesville WI
Janesville Mutuals 3, Milwaukee 6Game 1399 (GameID g09141877-09)
| Frank James | ss |
| Harry Arundel | rf & p |
| John Ward | p & rf |
| John Shoup | 2b |
| Bill Phillips | 1b |
| Frank Smith | cf |
| Doc Bushong | c |
| William Cantilion | lf |
| John Morrissey | 3b |
| Pidgey Morgan | 3b |
| Billy Redmond | ss |
| Fred Andrus | rf |
| Joe Ellick | cf |
| Abner Dalrymple | lf |
| Charlie Bennett | c |
| Hugh McDonald | 2b |
| Sam Weaver | p |
| Everett Mills | 1b |
