September 29, 1877 at
Brooklyn Chelsea 7, Orange 2Game 1534 (GameID g09291877-08)
| Dennis Clare | ss |
| John Hayes | lf |
| Ben Laughlin | 2b |
| Nick Hourigan | rf |
| Robert Rule | p |
| George Taylor | cf |
| John Dunne | 1b |
| Bill Schenck | 3b |
| John Curran | c |
| Ward | p |
| Shandley | lf |
| Ricker | 3b |
| Valentine | rf |
| Ripp | c |
| Smith | 2b |
| Smullen | ss |
| Kessler | 1b |
| Connelly | cf |
