The Reds played on game in 1877 before the club disbanded. The lineup was the same as that that finished the 1876, execpt Art Croft, who signed with the St. Louis Browns in the National League.
| Player | # games | Years with Reds | |
| Packy Dillon | 1 | 1873-1877 | Dillon played in St. Louis intermittantly for several years after the club disbanded in 1877. |
| Tom Dolan | 1 | 1875-1877 | Joined the Pittsburgh Alleghany of the International Association with Jim Galvin. |
| Jim Galvin | 1 | 1876-1877 | Joined the Pittsburgh Alleghany of the International Association with Tom DOlan. |
| Bill Gleason | 1 | 1876-1877 | Bill Gleason joined the Atlantics with Morgan in April. He signed with Minnesota in July, joining his brother Jack on the club. |
| Jack Gleason | 1 | 1876-1877 | Joined the Minneapolis Brown Stockings in May. |
| Dan Morgan | 1 | 1873-1877 | Played in more than 180 games from 1873-1877. Morgan joined the Atlantics with Bill Gleason in April. Later played with Minneapolis in the League Alliance. |
| Billy Redmond | 1 | 1873-1877 | Played in more than 180 games from 1873-1877. Signed by the Memphis Reds after the Reds folded. Later played with Cincinnati in the National League and Milwaukee in the League Alliance. |
| Tom Sullivan | 1 | 1876-1877 | Sullivan joined the Haymakers in April after the Reds folded. Signed with Evansville in early May. |
| White | 1 | 1874; 1876-1877 | White is identified as an old Reds sub in 1877 when he played in the final game for the club before it disbanded. |