April 16, 1877 at Columbus Buckeyes 7, Picked nine 1 GameID g04161877-01

Buckeyes cf Frank Fleet lf John Magner ss Mike Burke 2b George Strief c Billy Barnie 1b Chub Sullivan 3b Harry Spence p Jim McCormick rf Hunter

Picked Nine c Welsh 1b Robinson p Callahan ss Little 3b Maury 2b Martin cf Dunn lf Bear rf Burt

Picked nine @ Buckeyes
New York Mercury	Ohio State Journal