May 3, 1877 at Brooklyn NY Brooklyn Chelsea 4, New York Mutuals 1 GameID g05031877-05

Brooklyn Chelsea 3b Dennis Clare lf J Brennan 2b Ben Laughlin rf Nick Hourigan p Robert Rule ss James Roseman 1b John Dunne cf Thomas Cassidy c John Curran

New York Mutuals cf Heyman 2b Hackett 3b Sheppard lf Sullivan c Cramer p Cockran ss Hodge 1b Golden rf Tilly

New York Mutuals @ Brooklyn Chelsea
Brooklyn Daily Times	New York Daily Herald	New York Mercury