May 5, 1877 at New Haven CT
Yale 3, Brooklyn Chelsea 1
GameID g05051877-11
| Yale
| cf | McKnight | | c | Morgan | | 3b | Bigelow | | ss | Wheaton | | 2b | Clark | | rf | Williamson | | 1b | Downer | | p | Carter | | lf | Brown | | | Brooklyn Chelsea
| 3b | Dennis Clare | | lf | Thomas | | 2b | Ben Laughlin | | rf | Nick Hourigan | | p | Robert Rule | | ss | James Roseman | | 1b | John Dunne | | cf | Thomas Cassidy | | c | John Curran | |
