May 10, 1877 at Rochester Rochester 5, Erie 4 GameID g05101877-02

Rochester 2b Steve Brady cf Joe Simmons ss Harry Luff rf Ed Shattuck lf Jim Tipper 3b Jack Madden c Ed Caskin p Charles Purroy 1b Ed Pond

Erie @ Rochester
New York Clipper	New York Mercury	Rochester Democrat Chronicle	Rochester Times Union