May 11, 1877 at Guelph, Ont.
Maple Leaf 0, Allegheny 5GameID g05111877-03
| lf | Tommy Smith |
| rf | William Smith |
| ss | Richard Dixon |
| 3b & c | Marshall Quinton |
| 1b | William Lapham |
| cf & c | Scott Hastings |
| p | James Sullivan |
| 2b | Henry Gillespie |
| c, 3b & cf | Walsh |
| ss | Candy Nelson |
| 2b | Ed Williamson |
| c | Tom Dolan |
| 1b | Jake Goodman |
| 3b | Al Nichols |
| rf | Bill Holbert |
| lf | George Creamer |
| cf | Russ McKelvy |
| p | Pud Galvin |
