May 12, 1877 at Wheeling Wheeling Standard 4, Buckeyes 5 GameID g05121877-05

Buckeyes 2b Frank Fleet ss Mike Burke rf Eddie Booth cf John Magner p Edward Callahan 3b Harry Spence 1b Chub Sullivan c Billy Barnie lf George Strief

Buckeyes @ Wheeling Standard
New York Clipper	Wheeling Daily Register