May 15, 1877 at Syracuse NYSyracuse Stars 5, Allegheny 2GameID g05151877-02
| Allegheny ss Candy Nelson 2b Ed Williamson c Tom Dolan 1b Jake Goodman 3b Al Nichols rf Bill Holbert lf George Creamer cf Russ McKelvy p Pud Galvin |
| Allegheny @ Syracuse Stars | New York Mercury![]() |