May 18, 1877 at Binghamton
Crickets 1, Allegheny 2
GameID g05181877-02
| Crickets
| 1b | John McGuinness | | ss | John Richmond | | rf | Hardy Richardson | | 3b | Pop Smith | | cf | Art Allison | | 2b | Bobby Clack | | lf | Ed Kennedy | | c | Joseph Roche | | p | Nicholas Alcott | | | Allegheny
| ss | Candy Nelson | | 2b | Ed Williamson | | c | Tom Dolan | | 1b | Jake Goodman | | 3b | Al Nichols | | rf | Bill Holbert | | lf | George Creamer | | cf | Russ McKelvy | | p | Pud Galvin | |
