May 21, 1877 at Columbus
Buckeyes 9, Live Oak 3
GameID g05211877-01

| Buckeyes
| cf | Frank Fleet | | ss | Mike Burke | | rf | Eddie Booth | | lf | John Magner | | p | Edward Callahan | | 3b | Harry Spence | | 1b | Chub Sullivan | | c | Billy Barnie | | 2b | George Strief | | | Live Oak
| 2b | Thorny Hawkes | | lf | Charlie Mason | | p | Candy Cummings | | 1b | George Adams | | rf | Jack Allen | | c | Charlie Reilley | | ss | Henry Waren | | cf | Albert Carpenter | | 3b | John Gaffney | |