May 21, 1877 at Guelph
Maple Leaf 5, Athletic 4
GameID g05211877-02
| Maple Leaf
| lf | Tommy Smith | | cf | William Smith | | ss | Richard Dixon | | p | James Sullivan | | rf | Scott Hastings | | 1b | William Lapham | | 3b & c | Marshall Quinton | | 2b & 3b | Henry Gillespie | | c | Walsh | | 2b | James Hewer | | | Philadelphia Athletic
| cf | Dave Eggler | | 2b | John Shetzline | | rf | Al Reach | | 3b | William Coon | | 1b | Wes Fisler | | ss | Charles Fulmer | | lf | Johnny Ryan | | p | Sam Weaver | | c | Edward McGlynn | |
