May 23, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 4, Hartford 5
GameID g05231877-05
| Cincinnati
| lf | Ned Cuthbert | | cf | Lip Pike | | 1b | Charley Jones | | 2b | Jimmy Hallinan | | rf | Bob Addy | | ss | Amos Booth | | 3b | Will Foley | | c | Nat Hicks | | p | Bobby Mathews | | | Hartford
| cf | Jim Holdsworth | | 1b | Joe Start | | 2b | Jack Burdock | | ss | Tom Carey | | 3b | Bob Ferguson | | lf | Tom York | | rf | John Cassidy | | c | Doug Allison | | p | Terry Larkin | |
