May 24, 1877 at Erie
Erie 5, Live Oak 4GameID g05241877-03
16 innings
| 2b | Thorny Hawkes |
| 1b | Charlie Mason |
| p | Candy Cummings |
| lf | George Adams |
| ss | Jack Allen |
| cf | Charlie Reilley |
| c | James Moorehouse |
| rf | Albert Carpenter |
| 3b | John Gaffney |
May 24, 1877 at ErieErie 5, Live Oak 4GameID g05241877-03 16 innings
| Live Oak
|
| Live Oak @ Erie | New York Clipper |
New York Mercury |