May 24, 1877 at Guelph Maple Leaf 5, Syracuse Stars 4 GameID g05241877-04

Maple Leaf lf Tommy Smith cf William Smith ss Richard Dixon p James Sullivan rf Scott Hastings 1b William Lapham c Marshall Quinton 3b Henry Gillespie 2b James Hewer

Syracuse Stars rf Dick Higham ss Billy Geer 1b Alex McKinnon cf Pete Hotaling c Al Hall lf Mike Mansell 2b Jack Farrell p Harry McCormick 3b Hick Carpenter

Syracuse Stars @ Maple Leaf
Guelph Mercury	New York Clipper