June 4, 1877 at RochesterRochester 5, Buckeyes 2GameID g06041877-04
| Rochester 2b Steve Brady rf John Magner cf Harry Luff ss Ed Shattuck lf Jim Tipper 3b Jack Madden c Ed Caskin p Charles Purroy 1b Ed Pond | Buckeyes cf Frank Fleet ss Mike Burke rf Eddie Booth lf Charlie Pabor p Edward Callahan 3b Harry Spence 1b Chub Sullivan c Billy Barnie 2b George Strief |
| Buckeyes @ Rochester | New York Mercury![]() |
Ohio State Journal![]() |
Rochester Democrat Chronicle![]() |
Rochester Times Union![]() |