June 28, 1877 at GuelphMaple Leaf 2, Buckeyes 3GameID g06281877-03 12 innings
| Maple Leaf lf Tommy Smith cf William Smith ss Richard Dixon p James Sullivan 1b William Lapham 2b Marshall Quinton 3b Henry Gillespie rf Walsh c Mike Lawlor | Buckeyes 2b Frank Fleet ss Mike Burke lf Charlie Pabor cf Edward Callahan 3b Harry Spence 1b Chub Sullivan c Billy Barnie rf George Strief p Jim McCormick |
| Buckeyes @ Maple Leaf | Guelph Mercury![]() |
Ohio State Journal![]() |