August 23, 1877 at Rochester
Rochester 4, Syracuse Stars 5
GameID g08231877-05
| Rochester
| 2b | Steve Brady | | 3b | Ed Caskin | | cf | Harry Luff | | 1b | Charles Junkins | | c | Doc Kennedy | | ss | Ed Shattuck | | rf | Michael Hayes | | lf | Jim Tipper | | p | Ike Van Burkalow | | | Syracuse Stars
| 2b | Pete Hotaling | | c | Al Hall | | rf | Dick Higham | | 2b | Billy Geer | | ss | Jack Farrell | | p | Harry McCormick | | lf | Mike Mansell | | 1b | Hick Carpenter | | cf | Jim Clinton | |
