August 26, 1877 at Orange NJ Orange 3, Wilkes-Barre 11 GameID g08261877-02

Syracuse Stars ss Pete Hotaling 2b & c Al Hall rf Dick Higham 3b Jack Farrell p Harry McCormick c & 2b Jerry Dorgan lf Mike Mansell 1b Hick Carpenter cf Jim Clinton

Buckeyes c King Kelly ss Mike Burke lf Charlie Pabor 1b Chub Sullivan cf Edward Callahan 2b George Strief 3b Harry Spence p Jim McCormick rf Martin Nolan