September 21, 1877 at Milwaukee
Milwaukee 5, Allegheny 7
GameID g09211877-02
| Milwaukee
| 3b | Pidgey Morgan | | ss | Billy Redmond | | p | Fred Andrus | | cf | Charlie Bennett | | lf | Abner Dalrymple | | c | Joe Ellick | | 2b | Hugh McDonald | | rf | Sam Weaver | | 1b | Everett Mills | | | Allegheny
| cf | Russ McKelvy | | ss | Candy Nelson | | p | Pud Galvin | | 3b | Ed Williamson | | 2b | Charles Fulmer | | cf | Tom Dolan | | lf | George Creamer | | rf | Bill Holbert | | 1b | Jake Goodman | |
