September 22, 1877 at ChicagoSyracuse Stars 6, Allegheny 4GameID g09221877-03
| Allegheny 1b Russ McKelvy ss Candy Nelson p Pud Galvin 3b Ed Williamson 2b Charles Fulmer cf Tom Dolan lf George Creamer rf Bill Holbert cf Johnny Ryan |
| Allegheny @ Syracuse Stars | Chicago Tribune![]() |