September 25, 1877 at AlleghenyAllegheny 6, Syracuse Stars 4GameID g09251877-01
| Allegheny rf Russ McKelvy ss Candy Nelson p Pud Galvin 3b Ed Williamson 2b Charles Fulmer cf Tom Dolan lf George Creamer c Bill Holbert 1b Jake Goodman |
| Syracuse Stars @ Allegheny | Pittsburgh Post![]() |