September 25, 1877 at Pittsburgh
Allegheny 6, Syracuse Stars 4
GameID g09251877-01
| Allegheny
| rf | Russ McKelvy | | ss | Candy Nelson | | p | Pud Galvin | | 3b | Ed Williamson | | 2b | Charles Fulmer | | cf | Tom Dolan | | lf | George Creamer | | c | Bill Holbert | | 1b | Jake Goodman | | | Syracuse Stars
| c | Pete Hotaling | | ss | Billy Geer | | cf | Al Hall | | 1b | Alex McKinnon | | 2b | Jack Farrell | | p | Harry McCormick | | lf | Mike Mansell | | 3b | Hick Carpenter | | cf | Jim Clinton | |
