August 23, 1877 at Rochester
Rochester 4, Syracuse Stars 5GameID g08231877-05
| 2b | Steve Brady |
| 3b | Ed Caskin |
| cf | Harry Luff |
| 1b | Charles Junkins |
| c | Doc Kennedy |
| ss | Ed Shattuck |
| rf | Michael Hayes |
| lf | Jim Tipper |
| p | Ike Van Burkalow |
| 2b | Pete Hotaling |
| c | Al Hall |
| rf | Dick Higham |
| 2b | Billy Geer |
| ss | Jack Farrell |
| p | Harry McCormick |
| lf | Mike Mansell |
| 1b | Hick Carpenter |
| cf | Jim Clinton |
