May 4, 1877 at Columbus
Buckeyes 1, Boston 7
GameID g05041877-01

| Buckeyes
| lf | Frank Fleet | | ss | Mike Burke | | rf | Eddie Booth | | cf | John Magner | | p | Edward Callahan | | 3b | Harry Spence | | 1b | Chub Sullivan | | c | Billy Barnie | | 2b | George Strief | | | Boston
| ss | George Wright | | lf | Andy Leonard | | 1b | Deacon White | | rf | Jim O'Rourke | | 3b | Ezra Sutton | | p | Tommy Bond | | c | Lew Brown | | 2b | John Morrill | | cf | Tim Murnane | |