September 11, 1877 at Louisville
Louisville 12, Amateurs 9GameID g09111877-09
| 1b | Jumbo Latham |
| 3b | Al Nichols |
| lf | George Hall |
| p | Jim Devlin |
| rf | Orator Shafer |
| 3b | Al Nichols |
| ss | Bill Craver |
| cf | Flip Lafferty |
| cf | Bill Crowley |
| 1b | Haldeman |
| lf | Oyler |
| 2b | Browning |
| rf | Lambert |
| 3b | Robinson |
| c | Harvey McElwee |
| cf | Johnson |
| p | Willie McElwee |
| ss | Kennedy |
