September 18, 1877 at Rochester
Rochester 3, Buffalo 1GameID g09181877-04
| 2b | Steve Brady |
| 3b | Ed Caskin |
| cf | James Sullivan |
| 1b | Charles Junkins |
| c | Doc Kennedy |
| rf | Ed Shattuck |
| ss | Richard Dixon |
| lf | Jim Tipper |
| p | Ike Van Burkalow |
| 2b | Bill Fouser |
| c | Chappy Lane |
| lf | Edward McGlynn |
| 3b | Jack Glasscock |
| ss | Andy Cummins |
| 1b | Frank Heifer |
| cf | Marr Phillips |
| rf | John Shetzline |
| p | Larry Corcoran |
