May 23, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 4, Hartford 5GameID g05231877-05
| lf | Ned Cuthbert |
| cf | Lip Pike |
| 1b | Charley Jones |
| 2b | Jimmy Hallinan |
| rf | Bob Addy |
| ss | Amos Booth |
| 3b | Will Foley |
| c | Nat Hicks |
| p | Bobby Mathews |
| cf | Jim Holdsworth |
| 1b | Joe Start |
| 2b | Jack Burdock |
| ss | Tom Carey |
| 3b | Bob Ferguson |
| lf | Tom York |
| rf | John Cassidy |
| c | Doug Allison |
| p | Terry Larkin |
