May 31, 1877 at Cincinnati
Cincinnati 12, St. Louis 7GameID g05311877-05
| 2b | Jimmy Hallinan |
| cf | Lip Pike |
| ss | Jack Manning |
| rf | Bob Addy |
| lf | Charley Jones |
| 3b | Will Foley |
| c | Amos Booth |
| 1b | Charlie Gould |
| p | Bobby Mathews |
| lf | Mike Dorgan |
| c | John Clapp |
| 2b | Mike McGeary |
| 3b | Joe Battin |
| ss | Davy Force |
| cf | Jack Remsen |
| rf | Joe Blong |
| p | Tricky Nichols |
| 1b | Herman Dehlman |
