May 1, 1877 at AlleghenyAllegheny 0, Buckeyes 1GameID g05011877-01 Called after 4 innings due to snow and rain
| Allegheny ss Candy Nelson 2b Ed Williamson c Tom Dolan 1b Jake Goodman 3b Al Nichols rf Billy West lf George Creamer cf Russ McKelvy p Pud Galvin | Buckeyes lf Frank Fleet ss Mike Burke rf Eddie Booth cf John Magner p Edward Callahan 3b Harry Spence 1b Chub Sullivan c Billy Barnie 2b George Strief |
| Buckeyes @ Allegheny | New York Mercury![]() |
Pittsburgh Post Gazette![]() |