April 17, 1877 at Columbus
Buckeyes 6, Picked ten 0
GameID g04171877-01

| Buckeyes
| cf | Frank Fleet | | lf | John Magner | | ss | Mike Burke | | 2b | George Strief | | rf | Eddie Booth | | c | Billy Barnie | | 3b | Harry Spence | | 1b | Chub Sullivan | | p | Jim McCormick | | | Picked Ten
| c | Welsh | | 1b | Robinson | | p | Callahan | | ss | McGee | | 3b | Hunter | | 2b | Porter | | rf | Kline | | cf | Burt | | lf | Rice | | rf | Little | |